These items are only available for pickup at our Armonk, NY location. If you would like to order a custom decorated cake, please do not order a cake online and ask to add decorations. Please call us or email us to discuss instead, thanks you!
Don’t Live Near Our Bakery? View Nationwide Delivery Items
Our Christmas Menu is available all month long, for your gifting and party needs!
*IMPORTANT: No Cancellations or Refunds on Pre-orders
Christmas Dessert Board
$110.00
Santa Pull Away Cupcake Cake
$85.00
Elf or Rudolph the Reindeer Cookie Cake
$50.00
Christmas Funfetti Rainbow Crumb Cake
$60.00
Assorted Donuts (6-pack)
$25.00
Santa Baby Fancy Heart Cake
$75.00
Heat and Frost Cinnamon Rolls
$42.00
Decorate Your Own Cookies for Santa
$50.00
Christmas Chocolate Basket
STARTING AT
$60.00
Build Your Own SMALL Christmas Platter
STARTING AT
$55.00
Build Your Own MEDIUM Christmas Platter
STARTING AT
$85.00
Build Your Own LARGE Christmas Platter
STARTING AT
$140.00
Build Your Own Box
$60.00
Sugar-Hi's Greatest Hits
$105.00
Sugar-Hi's Cookie Sampler
$60.00